Architecture

Apply SOLID Principles Without Overengineering

Use SOLID as a set of design heuristics to manage change, not as a reason to create unnecessary abstractions.

SOLID principles help developers reason about how responsibilities and dependencies should be arranged. They are most useful when they reduce the cost of change. Applied mechanically, they can produce excessive interfaces, indirection, and classes that make a small feature harder to understand.

Single Responsibility Principle

A module should have one cohesive reason to change. Group code around a clear responsibility, such as calculating an invoice or sending a notification. Do not interpret this as a requirement that every method needs its own class.

Open/Closed Principle

Prefer designs where new behavior can be added without repeatedly editing stable decision logic. Strategies, handlers, and configuration-driven registries can help when variation is real. A simple conditional may still be clearer when the number of cases is small and unlikely to grow.

Liskov Substitution and Interface Segregation

An implementation should honor the behavioral contract expected by its callers. Interfaces should describe useful capabilities rather than force every implementation to support unrelated methods. Keep contracts small, documented, and testable.

Dependency Inversion

High-level policy should not depend directly on low-level details such as a particular mail provider or database driver. Introduce an abstraction at a meaningful boundary when it gives the application a real choice or test seam.

Apply principles pragmatically

Look for repeated change, unstable dependencies, and difficult tests before introducing patterns. Refactor incrementally and verify behavior with tests.

Checklist

  • Identify the change pressure before abstracting.
  • Keep responsibilities cohesive.
  • Define behavioral contracts, not just method names.
  • Avoid interfaces with only ceremonial value.
  • Reassess complexity after each refactor.
Share this page Help other developers discover this resource.