PHP enums provide a type-safe way to represent a fixed set of values. Attributes provide structured metadata that can be read through reflection. Both can improve clarity when used for stable concepts, but they should not become a substitute for simple configuration or explicit control flow.
Backed enums for persisted values
A backed enum associates each case with a string or integer value. This is useful for statuses, roles or workflow states that have a defined set of valid values. When values are stored in a database, treat the backing values as part of the persistence contract and plan migrations before renaming or removing them.
Validate external input
Convert external strings to enum cases deliberately and handle invalid values. Do not assume a request parameter is valid simply because an enum exists in the code. Use tryFrom for safe conversion when values may be unknown.
Attributes for metadata
Attributes can describe routes, validation rules, serialization hints or other metadata. A reflection-based system should validate attribute arguments and define deterministic behavior when metadata is missing or duplicated. Cache reflection results when repeated discovery becomes expensive.
Keep behavior discoverable
Use attributes when metadata is naturally attached to a class, method or property. If the behavior becomes difficult to trace, an explicit registry or configuration file may be easier for the team to maintain.
Checklist
- Use enums for genuinely finite domain values.
- Treat backed values as a stable data contract.
- Validate external input before enum conversion.
- Validate and cache reflection-based attribute processing.
- Prefer explicit configuration when metadata becomes opaque.